Rudolf Hess: Flight to Scotland, Sentence and Death in 1987

Eight core facts, one pattern: the dates and verdicts are documented, while the reasons behind them are the parts that stay contested.

Why was Rudolf Hess not sentenced to death?

The International Military Tribunal sat at Nuremberg from 20 November 1945 to 1 October 1946 (EBSCO Research Starters (reference database)). Hess was one of 24 Nazi leaders indicted, and the court convicted him on two of four counts, crimes against peace and conspiracy (EBSCO Research Starters, reference database).

According to Humans of History, history Q&A site, he was acquitted of war crimes and crimes against humanity.

Why did Rudolf Hess get life imprisonment?

• The sentence was life imprisonment, one of seven prison sentences at the trial, rather than death (according to Wikipedia, open encyclopedia).
• Soviet member Major-General Iona Nikitchenko filed a dissent arguing that the death sentence was warranted (according to Wikipedia, open encyclopedia).
• The judges’ individual reasoning is documented only in part, so the verdict is stated here without assigning motives.

Some popular accounts link the lighter sentence to Hess’s mental fragility and to his captivity during the worst atrocities. History Crunch (history blog) makes that case, but the claim is rated low confidence and the tribunal record does not confirm it.

The catch: the sentence is documented, but the reasoning behind it is only partly on record, so explanations of leniency deserve caution.

What happened to Rudolf Hess in Scotland?

Hess took off alone from Augsburg in a Messerschmitt Bf 110 on the evening of 10 May 1941, carrying peace proposals that Hitler had not authorized (Britannica, encyclopedia). He bailed out near Floors Farm in Eaglesham, south of Glasgow, injured his ankle and asked to see the Duke of Hamilton (BBC News (public broadcaster)).

Sources differ on the exact landing spot and the takeoff time, so this article uses only the date and the evening. According to Wikipedia, open encyclopedia, the crash lay about 12 miles from Dungavel House, the Duke of Hamilton’s home.

Why did Rudolf Hess fly to Scotland in 1941?

• Britannica describes the flight as a peace mission undertaken without Hitler’s authorization.
• BBC News (public broadcaster) called it an apparently unauthorised peace mission that Hitler denounced.
• Speer’s memoirs record Hess saying in Spandau that the flight was inspired by a dream (World History Encyclopedia (historical reference)).

The strongest evidence for intent is Hess’s own pitch as Speer recorded it: Britain would keep its empire in return for a free hand in Europe (World History Encyclopedia, historical reference). That evidence comes from a memoir written by a fellow prisoner, not from a contemporary document.

The trade-off: the stated aim is documented, but the reason behind it rests on a single memoir.

What was Hitler’s reaction to Rudolf Hess?

Hitler rejected the mission and accused Hess of “pacifist delusions” (Britannica, encyclopedia). The Nazi Party then declared him insane, a public line that presented the flight as the act of a sick man rather than a question of policy (Britannica, encyclopedia).

Hitler’s private reaction is not documented in the sources reviewed, and accounts of it conflict, so this article does not state one.

The implication: the public verdict of insanity and the private reaction are different records, and only the public one is documented in full.

Did Rudolf Hess actually lose his memory?

Hess claimed amnesia during his captivity, and the claim became a central question of his trials and detention (according to Wikipedia, open encyclopedia).

Rudolf Hess amnesia

• Psychiatric panels judged Hess abnormal but fit to stand trial (according to Wikipedia, open encyclopedia).
• The individual examiners’ reports are not among the sources reviewed, so these findings come through a summary.
• Hess later admitted that the amnesia was simulated, according to the same summary (Wikipedia, open encyclopedia).

Read together, these findings neither prove nor disprove the amnesia. The record shows a claim, an examination and an admission, and the admission itself comes from a secondary account.

The catch: a dispute over claimed amnesia is only as strong as the examination reports behind it, and those reports are the missing piece here.

Why did Hess hang himself?

Hess died on 17 August 1987 at Spandau Prison in West Berlin, aged 93, and was found hanged in a garden summer house (Britannica, encyclopedia). The official Spandau news release said he hanged himself from a window bar with an electric cord and was pronounced dead at 4:10 pm at the British Military Hospital (The National Interest (foreign policy journal)).

Rudolf Hess cause of death

• The Washington Post reported in 1987 that Hess had attempted suicide three times while imprisoned (The Washington Post (1987 news archive)).
• Hess’s son, Wolf Rüdiger Hess, claimed that British intelligence murdered his father (according to Wikipedia, open encyclopedia).
• Hess’s lawyer, Alfred Seidl, argued that he was too old and frail to take his own life (according to Wikipedia, open encyclopedia).

The Four-Powers Authority ruled the death a suicide on 17 September 1987 (according to Wikipedia, open encyclopedia). A challenge questioned whether the cord height allowed a hanging, a point the Scotland Yard report dismissed (The Daily Star, UK newspaper).

The implication: the official finding is suicide, but the motive is not established by documented evidence, so the question of why stays open even where the how is recorded.

Key dates from birth to death

Ten dates, one pattern: the record is dense around the flight and the trial, then thins through the custody years until the 1987 death sets off the disputes.

What this means: the dated record is firmest at the edges of Hess’s life, the flight and the death, while the decades in between survive mostly as custody notes.

Confirmed facts and open questions

Confirmed facts

• Hess flew from Augsburg on 10 May 1941 and was captured after landing (Britannica, encyclopedia).
• Britain held him as a prisoner of war through the end of the war (Britannica, encyclopedia).
• Hess became the sole prisoner at Spandau in 1966 (Britannica, encyclopedia).
• A DNA study found a 99.99 percent likelihood that the Spandau prisoner and Hess’s relatives were related, disproving the double theory (Smithsonian Magazine, science journalism).

What’s unclear

• The real motive for the flight: Speer’s memoir offers a dream and a bid for prestige, but no contemporary document confirms either (World History Encyclopedia, historical reference).
• Whether the amnesia was genuine, given the claim and the later admission that it was simulated (according to Wikipedia, open encyclopedia).
• Whether the 1987 death was murder: the family says yes, and the 1989 review found no cogent evidence (The Daily Star, UK newspaper).
• Whether a 2012 declassified-document report changed the picture: according to Wikipedia, open encyclopedia, it renewed questions, but no independent source in this review verifies it.
• Whether repeated Western requests to release Hess were made: according to Humans of History, history Q&A site, Soviet opposition blocked them, but no primary source confirms repeated petitions.

The trade-off: the confirmed list is short because the documents are thin, not because the story is simple, so each rumor deserves to be held at arm’s length.

In their own words

Three voices from the record, each with a stake in how the story is told.

“Hess was probably trying, after so many years of being kept in the background, to win prestige and some success.”

Albert Speer, memoirs, quoted by World History Encyclopedia (historical reference)

“The inquiries carried out by Detective Chief Superintendent Jones have produced no cogent evidence to suggest that Rudolf Hess was murdered.”

Sir Nicholas Lyell, Solicitor General, speaking in Parliament, November 1989, reported by The Daily Star (UK newspaper)

“We will guarantee England her empire; in return she will give us a free hand in Europe.”

Rudolf Hess, as recorded by Albert Speer, via World History Encyclopedia (historical reference)

The catch: Hess’s own pitch and Speer’s gloss point toward intent, while the 1989 review points away from murder, and neither set of words settles why he did what he did.

Where the record stops

The next meaningful evidence would be primary material, such as full examination reports or the complete Nuremberg judgment text, and the sources reviewed for this piece include neither. Readers who meet this story in a film or documentary should accept the flight, the 1946 life sentence and the 1987 suicide ruling as documented, and demand primary records before repeating any claim about his motive or his death.

Related reading: Andy Warhol: Life, Shooting, Art, and Myths · Samuel Pepys: Diary, Great Fire of London, and Naval Career

Frequently asked questions